The image of Makar Nagulnov in M. Sholokhov’s novel “Virgin Soil Upturned”
In the novel “Virgin Soil Upturned,” Sholokhov reproduces the complex process of the liquidation of the old system in the village in the 30s of the twentieth century and the birth of a new village. The central place in the novel is occupied by the people. The writer describes different destinies, the struggle for and against a new life.
One of the ardent fighters for a bright future in “Virgin Soil Upturned” is Makar Nagulnov, secretary of the Gremyachensk party cell, a Red Banner member. He fought heroically in the civil war, “cut down the reptiles mercilessly,” was shell-shocked, and received an order.
Nagulnov is an ardent opponent of property. Back in 1920, guided by hatred of her, he joined a commune, which disintegrated “from selfishness.” He then gave his bulls to the neighboring commune, but he and his wife have nothing.
Even as a young man, Makar saw the trouble that property brought. He became convinced that the fight for it would discord people, lead them to serious crimes, and disfigure them.
souls.
The creation of a collective farm for Nagulnov is a holy and right thing. “We need to bury ourselves in the ground and lure everyone into the collective farm,” he says. The hero sincerely believes that this will make not only him, Makar, happy, but the whole Gremyachiy Log, the whole country, the whole world. “It will be charm, not life!” - Nagulnov sincerely exclaims.
Already at the very beginning of the novel it is said about him that he is “harsh, all corners, and... all sharp.” In the fight for the idea, Makar really reaches the point of fanaticism, bordering on madness. He is ready to give his life for Soviet power, not only his own, but also that of others: “Yes, I... kill thousands of grandfathers, children, women... Yes, tell me that they need to be sprayed. For the revolution it is necessary.. I will kill them all with a machine gun!” At these words, the hero’s dilated pupils sparkle with rage, foam boils at the corners of his lips.
Nagulnov sacredly and blindly believes in the world revolution, and intends to fight for it by any means necessary. Solving problems with the help of force, a revolver, a gun - this is his fighting style, his way.
Meeting with Titk, who is leading the sale of his bulls, Makar is hot and angry. In this state, he has poor control over his actions and shows lack of restraint. So Nagulnov hits individual farmer Bannik on the head with a revolver, forcing him to take seed grain to the public barn, and with a revolver in his hands he defends the collective farm barn from rebellious women.
Makar has to answer for his actions. In the district committee, his terrible anger disappears without a trace and is replaced by uncertainty and fear. Nagulnov is not afraid of severe punishment, but of exclusion from building a bright future. “Where am I without a party?” - he asks in confusion, killed by the sounded decision and returns to Gremyachiy completely exhausted.
People like Makar are directly affected, although not entirely fair, by Stalin’s article “Dizziness from success.” She “pierced Nagulnov right through”, “combustible blood” boiled in him. The hero is offended because he “grew to the party ... with his heart and with the blood shed.”
Nagulnov evokes conflicting feelings. He is a romantic, dreaming of a world revolution, and many of his mistakes are explained not only by his hot temper, but also by his political illiteracy, lack of experience and basic culture. Makar is no stranger to generosity and the ability to respond to the pain of others. He is straightforward and honest. Having discovered the hiding Ragged, Makar does not shoot him in the back, as would be simpler and safer, but orders him to turn around.
The unsettled nature of his personal life evokes sympathy. Nagulnov’s wife Lushka openly meets with Timofey, the son of Frol Damaskov. And the most offensive and humiliating thing for Makar is that Timofey is a fist. Nagulnov is capable of tender feelings. “I love you,” he says to Lushka, “I would have endured a lot of shame.” And if in the fight for new system Makar is irreconcilable, but in building a relationship with Lushka he does not find such determination in himself. “The woman has smeared you into the board!.. You’re a deck! Bull rennet!” - Davydov tells him incredulously, to which Makar replies: “I can’t beat her.”
Of course, Nagulnov is a man of extreme judgments. His indomitable temperament constantly makes itself felt; in problematic situations, it is not his reason that takes over, but the element of emotion. But listening to a rooster’s singing reveals Makar’s subtle and sensitive nature.
He has a craving for self-education, for growth, for which he sits over books until the morning.
The hero's speech is touching. It organically combines dialectisms with words from political and scientific literature. Makar has a very vague idea of their meaning, so he often uses them distortedly, in non-local combinations, and this combination gives the hero’s language a unique flavor.
The novel ends tragically. Makar Nagulnov dies. I feel sorry for the hero, who gave all the ardor, all the heat of his nature, all the warmth of his feelings to accomplish the fight against dissidents and did not realize this.
/ / / The image of Makar Nagulnov in Sholokhov’s novel “Virgin Soil Upturned”
Mikhail Alexandrovich Sholokhov's novel "" is replete with diversity unforgettable images, one of these was the portrait of a communist, wholeheartedly devoted to the party, Makar Nagulny.
This hero is distinguished by his blind adherence to the idea of world revolution; he is devoted to the party cause to the marrow of his bones. Harsh and impetuous, Nagulnov shows impatience in all situations. This is due, first of all, to the fact that this person wants to achieve universal happiness and prosperity here and now, and he does not intend to wait for anything.
All enemies of the Soviet regime are his personal enemies, and he feels a burning hatred towards them. And Makar sees the main evil of the current situation in the presence of private property, which is why it is necessary to get rid of it.
Nagulnov perceives the call to unite everything into a collective farm with delight. He considers this idea not just true, but the ultimate truth. Then, Makar thinks, a truly wonderful life will begin.
Nagulnov was a participant civil war, even has an order. Collectivization on the Don is a new battle for Makar, and he rushes into this abyss with courage and determination to complete the job he has started.
Makar Nagulnov is a man with a romantic nature; he is driven by a bright dream of achieving a world revolution. But sometimes this hero forgets about reality, commits unthinkable acts, such as, for example, he is not at all against being shot for slaughtering cattle.
Nagulnov knows no doubts, he acts at the behest of a momentary impulse, therefore he often makes gross mistakes, thereby not helping, but, on the contrary, harming the cause of collectivization.
Makar does not know how to read and write. He is a very impulsive person, reacts sharply and quickly to all provocations from his opponents. So, for example, he rushes into a fight with Bannik, who offers to give the bread to the pigs, and not put it in the barn for public use. And Makar does not tolerate jokes about what is so dear to his heart. Again, he has a quarrel with Bannik because of the latter’s ridicule of socialism.
True, not everything is so simple in the character of Makar Nagulnov. He knows how to admit his mistakes. Over time, the hero understands that it is necessary to strengthen the created collective economy, and not blindly chase percentages and numbers.
As for his personal life, there are scenes in the novel that reflect these moments in Nagulnov’s life. Makar is in love with Lushka, deeply and strongly, although he tries to hide his feelings behind feigned severity. But actions speak louder than words. Nagulnov releases the girl from arrest, allowing her to avoid responsibility.
Makar's death was as quick and chaotic as his whole life. He recklessly rushed at the enemies of Soviet power and died. The author describes this moment sparingly, but bitter and sad notes are still felt in his few words. Now the wheat will rustle along Nagulny and Davydov, and the nameless river, originating from the upper reaches of Gremyachey Log, will ring over the stones. That's all.
One of the most colorful and memorable images described in M. Sholokhov’s novel “Virgin Soil Upturned” is the image of Makar Nagulnov, a former Red partisan, secretary of the Gremyachen party cell. The only purpose of his, Nagulnov’s, existence is the “world revolution”.
Many residents of Gremyachey Log do not like and are even afraid of Makar, who is very intemperate with his tongue and, on occasion, may well use his fist, or even a revolver. Having received a shell shock during the war, Nagulnov is susceptible to nervous attacks - needless to say, it’s really better to stay on your guard with such things.
But at the same time, Makar Nagulnov’s nature is also characterized by some specific idealism, which is not immediately visible behind his gloomy appearance, harsh statements and sometimes unpredictable behavior. It’s as if he was created entirely from contradictions... “from sharp corners.”
At the beginning of the novel, after the scenes of dispossession, Davydov, Nagulnov and Razmetnov discuss the results of the “events taken.” When Razmetnov admitted that he was painfully sorry for the children of the dispossessed Gaev, Nagulnov flew into a rage and screamed hysterically that if for the sake of the revolution he was ordered to machine-gun crowds of women, old people and children, he would not hesitate to pull the trigger. After this, Nagulnov has a seizure.
But the same Nagulnov frees his ex-wife Lushka immediately after he killed her lover - the dispossessed Timofey Rvany, who escaped from exile. What's the matter here? Even Davydov, I think, would have acted differently in this situation. He lets go because he loves her; lets him go, despite the fact that she caused him a lot of mental suffering with her behavior; releases him, knowing full well that he may well be punished for this.
Makar Nagulnov sincerely considers himself a communist. But with all this, he often does not agree with the line pursued by the party, for which he receives a scolding from Davydov. When the district authorities decide to “sacrifice” Makar by expelling him from the party ranks, it seems to him that his life is over. Having set off from the district back to the farm after the ill-fated meeting, Nagulnov firmly decides that when he arrives home he will wear military uniform and shoot himself with his revolver.
But on the way to Gremyachiy he changed his mind. Lying near the mound on the grass, looking into the bottomless sky, Makar suddenly imagines how his enemies will gloat at his funeral, and his train of thoughts completely changes. The enemies will not wait for him, Makar Nagulnov, to take his own life. Previously, he would put them all to the grave first.
Nagulnov is undoubtedly a brave man, even brave to the point of recklessness. When men and women began to rob the collective farm barns, he alone stood up against the angry crowd and, threatening with a revolver, prevented the theft of collective farm property.
In order to find and kill Timofey Rvany, he begins to follow him alone. After all, when they learned that the escaped Timofey had shown up in their area, Davydov first suggested reporting him to the regional OGPU. But Nagulnov is adamant - there is no need to call the security officers, otherwise their arrival could “scare off the wolf.”
The scene of the murder of Timofey Rvany is also noteworthy. After all, he came out of the darkness towards Makar in such a way that he could only press the trigger. But nevertheless, Nagulnov calls out to the enemy so that he looks into the eyes of his death. In this case, there is every reason to say that Makar’s nature is characterized by genuine, natural, or something like, nobility. And it seems that he would not have fired a machine gun at children and women, as he threatened on the eve of the seizure. He obviously said this in the heat of the moment.
Nagulnov’s personal life is very peculiar. Knowing full well that his wife Lushka is confused with Timofey Rvany, and in general strict behavior no different, Makar, however, allows her to do whatever her heart desires. The only condition: do not spoil the child and do not bring a “bad disease” into the house. It seems that not every man could do this.
When Makar finally kicks Lushka out of the house, it turns out that he did this because she was shouting in front of all the honest people about Timofey, who was being sent into exile. Nagulnov can no longer forgive her for such public disgrace.
And then, when Lushka lured Davydov into her network, Makar is not at all jealous and has no claims against Semyon. He is only sorry that he ex-wife chose his comrade as the next “victim”. But even after this, as it turned out later, Nagulnov did not stop loving Lushka, letting her go on the night of Timofey’s death.
Makar Nagulnov also has other, more harmless eccentricities. The first is, of course, a passion for the English language. In almost four months, Makar learned... eight English words, moreover, the words, from his point of view, are “particularly revolutionary”: “revolutionary”, “communistic”, etc.
According to Makar, knowledge foreign language he needed it in order to take the most active and active part in the world revolution at the first opportunity. As soon as the English, “Indian” and other proletarians overthrow the capitalists, he, Makar, will immediately go to his class brothers and explain to them what needs to be done so as not to repeat the mistakes of their Russian comrades.
It is quite clear that this “Sisyphean labor”, which Nagulnov voluntarily shouldered, will never bring results either for objective or subjective reasons. And the very idea of a world revolution, which occupied the minds of the Bolsheviks, ultimately turned out to be untenable and was removed from the agenda, although Makar did not live to see this time and did not experience disappointment, did not see the collapse of the goal he was striving for. After all, it was with her that he connected his entire life and all his hopes, quite sincerely sacrificing all of himself and his human feelings to the idol of the world revolution.
Another sincere hobby of Nagulnov is also noteworthy: at night, studying English language, he listened to the roosters crowing. It would seem a rather strange occupation for a “knight of the world revolution,” but let’s try to figure out what the reason is.
Perhaps, in Nagulnov’s passion for cock crowing, his subconscious craving for nothing more nor less than Harmony with a capital “H” found a way out. In fact, the contradictory world in which he lives did not suit Makar: some want to create a collective farm, others do not want to and, moreover, actively oppose it. But the cock choir sings solemnly and smoothly, regardless of what political regime is established in the country.
True, among the roosters there was an “opportunist” who introduced disharmony into the harmonious choir of the Gremyachen roosters. And Makar immediately pronounces his verdict: like any “disagreeer” with the general line, a rooster that spoils the general singing must be destroyed. It seems that this act of Nagulnov also reveals the secrets of his soul.
Makar is generally a rather rude person when dealing with people. He is especially rude when communicating with grandfather Shchukar. True, the grandfather himself also often gets carried away in his stories and reasoning, and then Nagulnov immediately tries to shut up the old man, who is intemperate in his speeches.
Shchukar is indeed quite capable of disrupting the smooth flow of a collective farm meeting: when, for example, the question of the production rate of collective farmers is on the agenda, the grandfather, as if nothing had happened, begins to talk in great detail about how a Cossack nicknamed Silent drove even priest in confession... Of course, Shchukar is not a rooster, and cutting off his head, at least at a meeting, is not possible, but Nagulnov again, as in the case of the “opportunist rooster,” is tormented by a feeling of disharmony.
And then Makar turns out to be, in fact, the only participant in the meeting who wants to shut up the talkative grandfather. Even Davydov, who was initially angry with Shchukar, laughs like a child. Makar finds himself alone again.
And yet, it was idealists like Nagulnov who made the revolution, sacrificing themselves in the most literal sense. And then, following their bones, party functionaries came to power.
One of the most colorful and memorable images described in M. Sholokhov’s novel “Virgin Soil Upturned” is the image of Makar Nagulnov, a former Red partisan, secretary of the Gremyachen party cell. The only purpose of his, Nagulnov’s, existence is the “world revolution”.
Many residents of Gremyachey Log do not like and are even afraid of Makar, who is very intemperate with his tongue and, on occasion, may well use his fist, or even a revolver. Having received a shell shock during the war, Nagulnov is susceptible to nervous attacks - needless to say, it’s really better to stay on your guard with such things.
But at the same time, Makar Nagulnov’s nature is also characterized by some specific idealism, which is not immediately visible behind his gloomy appearance, harsh statements and sometimes unpredictable behavior. It’s as if he was created entirely from contradictions “from sharp corners.”
At the beginning of the novel, after the scenes of dispossession, Davydov, Nagulnov and Razmetnov discuss the results of the “events taken.” When Razmetnov admitted that he was painfully sorry for the children of the dispossessed Gaev, Nagulnov flew into a rage and screamed hysterically that if for the sake of the revolution he was ordered to machine-gun crowds of women, old people and children, he would not hesitate to pull the trigger. After this, Nagulnov has a seizure.
But the same Nagulnov frees his ex-wife Lushka immediately after he killed her lover - the dispossessed Timofey Rvany, who escaped from exile. What's the matter here? Even Davydov, I think, would have acted differently in this situation. He lets go because he loves her; lets him go, despite the fact that she caused him a lot of mental suffering with her behavior; releases him, knowing full well that he may well be punished for this.
Makar Nagulnov sincerely considers himself a communist. But with all this, he often does not agree with the line pursued by the party, for which he receives a scolding from Davydov. When the district authorities decide to “sacrifice” Makar by expelling him from the party ranks, it seems to him that his life is over. Having set off from the district back to the farm after the ill-fated meeting, Nagulnov firmly decides that, upon arriving home, he will put on a military uniform and shoot himself with his revolver.
But on the way to Gremyachiy he changed his mind. Lying near the mound on the grass, looking into the bottomless sky, Makar suddenly imagines how his enemies will gloat at his funeral, and his train of thoughts completely changes. The enemies will not wait for him, Makar Nagulnov, to take his own life. Previously, he would put them all to the grave first.
Nagulnov is undoubtedly a brave man, even brave to the point of recklessness. When men and women began to rob the collective farm barns, he alone stood up against the angry crowd and, threatening with a revolver, prevented the theft of collective farm property.
In order to find and kill Timofey Rvany, he begins to follow him alone. After all, when they learned that the escaped Timofey had shown up in their area, Davydov first suggested reporting him to the regional OGPU. But Nagulnov is adamant - there is no need to call the security officers, otherwise their arrival could “scare off the wolf.”
The scene of the murder of Timofey Rvany is also noteworthy. After all, he came out of the darkness towards Makar in such a way that he could only press the trigger. But nevertheless, Nagulnov calls out to the enemy so that he looks into the eyes of his death. In this case, there is every reason to say that Makar’s nature is characterized by genuine, natural, or something like, nobility. And it seems that he would not have fired a machine gun at children and women, as he had threatened on the eve of the seizure. He obviously said this in the heat of the moment.
Nagulnov’s personal life is very peculiar. Knowing full well that his wife Lushka is confused with Timofey Rvany, and in general does not differ in strict behavior, Makar, nevertheless, allows her to do whatever her heart desires. The only condition: do not spoil the child and do not bring a “bad disease” into the house. It seems that not every man could do this.
When Makar finally kicks Lushka out of the house, it turns out that he did this because she was shouting in front of all the honest people about Timofey, who was being sent into exile. Nagulnov can no longer forgive her for such public disgrace.
And then, when Lushka lured Davydov into her network, Makar is not at all jealous and has no claims against Semyon. He is only sorry that his ex-wife chose his comrade as the next “victim”. But even after this, as it turned out later, Nagulnov did not stop loving Lushka, letting her go on the night of Timofey’s death.
Makar Nagulnov also has other, more harmless eccentricities. The first is, of course, a passion for the English language. In almost four months, Makar learned eight English words, moreover, words, from his point of view, “especially revolutionary”: “revolutionary”, “communistic”, etc.
According to Makar, he needed knowledge of a foreign language in order to take the most active and active part in the world revolution at the first opportunity. As soon as the English, “Indian” and other proletarians overthrow the capitalists, he, Makar, will immediately go to his class brothers and explain to them what needs to be done so as not to repeat the mistakes of their Russian comrades.
It is quite clear that this “Sisyphean labor”, which Nagulnov voluntarily shouldered, will never bring results either for objective or subjective reasons. And the very idea of a world revolution, which occupied the minds of the Bolsheviks, ultimately turned out to be untenable and was removed from the agenda, although Makar did not live to see this time and did not experience disappointment, did not see the collapse of the goal he was striving for. After all, it was with her that he connected his entire life and all his hopes, quite sincerely sacrificing all of himself and his human feelings to the idol of the world revolution.
Another sincere hobby of Nagulnov is also noteworthy: at night, while studying English, he listened to the crowing of roosters. It would seem a rather strange occupation for a “knight of the world revolution,” but let’s try to figure out what the reason is.
Perhaps, in Nagulnov’s passion for cock crowing, his subconscious craving for nothing more nor less than Harmony with a capital “H” found a way out. In fact, the contradictory world in which he lives did not suit Makar: some want to create a collective farm, others do not want to and, moreover, actively oppose it. But the cock choir sings solemnly and smoothly, regardless of what political regime is established in the country.
True, among the roosters there was an “opportunist” who introduced disharmony into the harmonious choir of the Gremyachen roosters. And Makar immediately pronounces his verdict: like any “disagreeer” with the general line, a rooster that spoils the general singing must be destroyed. It seems that this act of Nagulnov also reveals the secrets of his soul.
Makar is generally a rather rude person when dealing with people. He is especially rude when communicating with grandfather Shchukar. True, the grandfather himself also often gets carried away in his stories and reasoning, and then Nagulnov immediately tries to shut up the old man, who is intemperate in his speeches.
Shchukar is indeed quite capable of disrupting the smooth flow of a collective farm meeting: when, for example, the question of the production rate of collective farmers is on the agenda, the grandfather, as if nothing had happened, begins to talk in great detail about how a Cossack nicknamed Silent drove even butt in confession. Of course, Shchukar is not a rooster, and cutting off his head, at least at a meeting, is not possible, but Nagulnov again, as in the case of the “opportunist rooster,” is tormented by a feeling of disharmony. And then Makar turns out to be, in fact, the only participant in the meeting who wants to shut up the talkative grandfather. Even Davydov, who was initially angry with Shchukar, laughs like a child. Makar finds himself alone again.
And yet, it was idealists like Nagulnov who made the revolution, sacrificing themselves in the most literal sense. And then, following their bones, party functionaries came to power.